Buffy the Vampire Slayer, season 3

Season 3 might very well be the greatest season of them all if I'd taken the time to look at average episode-scores. Still, there's a few things lacking that other seasons have going for them...

It's the final year of high school, a new player arrives to shake up the line between good and evil, we get introduced to The Mayor, it's the final season before Angel goes off to the spin-off world of L.A., and the Buffyverse get familiar with a whole new set of supernatural as werewolves and witchcraft are just a couple of elements taken further.

Honestly; it's increasingly difficult to say something useful about seasons without spoilers, so I'll just skip to the episode ratings if that's okay with you...

3.01 ★★★★★ Anne
3.02 ★★★☆☆ Dead Man's Party
3.03 ★★☆☆☆ Faith, Hope and Trick
3.04 ★★★★☆ Beauty and the Beasts
3.05 ★★★☆☆ Homecoming
3.06 ★★★☆☆ Band Candy
3.07 ★★★☆☆ Revelations
3.08 ★★★★☆ Lover's Walk
3.09 ★★★★★ The Wish
3.10 ★★★★★ Amends
3.11 ★★☆☆☆ Gingerbread
3.12 ★★★★☆ Helpless
3.13 ★★★☆☆ The Zeppo
3.14 ★★★☆☆ Bad Girls
3.15 ★★★★☆ Consequences
3.16 ★★★☆☆ Doppelgangland
3.17 ★★★★☆ Enemies
3.18 ★★★★☆ Earshot
3.19 ★★★★☆ Choices
3.20 ★★★★☆ The Prom
3.21 ★★★★★ Graduation Day (1)
3.22 ★★★★★ Graduation Day (2)

S.3 ★★★★★

For now I'll drop my photo-montages down memory lane, as they get increasingly spoiler-ish just by showing who's in them by now. At least for those lucky few who's yet to get into the magic of Sunnydale and the Buffyverse. My episode-wabbles might however become slightly more spoiler-ish as a result.

The big news of this season is Faith, called upon as Kendra died last season. She doesn't just shake things up, but give Buffy new challenges on most fronts throughout the season. Compared to Faith, the big bad of the season isn't all that. The other important arch is of course the Angel-kind. I for one wasn't to sad that particular saga came to an end, as his layers was mostly played out. Unlike my man Spike, Angel really couldn't hold my interest too long.

3.01 Anne

I really enjoyed the opener of the season. As Buffy ran away at the end of the last, we catch-up with her alone in the big city. Not only is her lonesome torments interesting, but also the case of the week have stuff going for it. It's only the opening of season six that starts of better.

3.04 Beauty and the Beasts

The case of the week side isn't very interesting, but Buffy's personal life get increasingly interesting with the return of her former lover.

3.09 The Wish

The second 5-rating of the season brings us an alternate reality as Cordelia Chase gets her wish. How would life have been in Sunnydale if Buffy never came there? Somewhat funny, somewhat deep and all the way enjoyable.

3.10 Amends

Some prepare for Christmas, and other struggles with the ghosts of murders past. In hindsight I clearly remember quite a few scenes and moments later on in the show that elevated far past this big one, but it did get emotional there for a while...

3.13 The Zeppo

I always found Xander's storylines mostly boring, and I quite frankly did so here as well, but the interesting part is really the way they turned this episode up-side down by following the B-story rather than the A-story. It makes playful use of cliches, and take more than a few stabs at their own 'verse. Nothing like a little self-awareness to remind us they're not full of them self.

3.21 & 3.22 Graduation Day (1&2)

The last half of the season is really all of very high standard, but it's not until the final two episodes they manage to hit top scores again. The Mayor, Faith, Angel, Ascension and --once again-- choices, are keywords to the end of another season. A season of high quality, but personally I think they managed to hit the really high heights of the show later on....

Buffy the Vampire Slayer, season 2

As I mentioned in my season 1 post, season two is really where it all started to make sense, and elevate from the cheese to something larger. It's also the first season to get five stars-episodes from me, and no less than 4 of them from the second half of the season... making episodes 13-22 of season 2 the first really great stretch of Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

BtVS becomes emotional and personal, and the Hellmouth-ian take of The Master in season 1 becomes a minor problem in hindsight. Back then all solutions seemed to at least be simple...

It's also the season Big Bad enters Buffy's world, and he's an insurance for great entertainment. It's no coincidence that character ranks extremely high in Sci-Fi polls, despite being antagonist rather than protagonist... It speaks greatly to the achievements of actor James Marsters, creator and showrunner Joss Whedon, and the rest of the writing staff in bringing to life --or un-death, as it may be-- a truly fascinating character with wit.

2.01 ★★★☆☆ When She Was Bad
2.02 ★★☆☆☆ Some Assembly Required
2.03 ★★★★☆ School Hard
2.04 ★★☆☆☆ Inca Mummy Girl
2.05 ★★☆☆☆ Reptile Boy
2.06 ★★★★☆ Halloween
2.07 ★★★☆☆ Lie to Me
2.08 ★★☆☆☆ The Dark Age
2.09 ★★★★☆ What's My Line? (1)
2.10 ★★★☆☆ What's My Line? (2)
2.11 ★★☆☆☆ Ted
2.12 ★★☆☆☆ Bad Eggs
2.13 ★★★★★ Surprise (1)
2.14 ★★★★★ Innocence (2)
2.15 ★★★☆☆ Phases
2.16 ★★★☆☆ Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered
2.17 ★★★★★ Passion
2.18 ★★★☆☆ Killed by Death
2.19 ★★★★☆ I Only Have Eyes For You
2.20 ★★☆☆☆ Go Fish
2.21 ★★★★☆ Becoming, Part 1 (1)
2.22 ★★★★★ Becoming, Part 2 (2)

S.2 ★★★★☆

So. While I won't go deep into spoiler-territory this season either, I'll still dip my toe into a couple of the mini-spoiler'ish positives from it. And I'll once again do one of my vintage photo-montages of the season, --again-- with a few spoilers I'm afraid...

The main archs of the season are twofold; Spike and Drusilla arrives as main opponents and old pals of Angel, and then the Buffy and Angel saga continues to unfold with some interesting curveballs thrown into the mix. It's also a season where Whedon starts making small changes to the premises we've taken for granted in the Buffyverse, and in most cases with a lot of luck. More importantly; this was the season the cheese and silliness elevated to inside jokes and excellent wit. On my first visit it won me over a few episodes further out than on this revisit, but then again it speaks to a greater achievement that the full knowledge makes it possible to enjoy some episodes, scenes and jokes even more on the revisit.

2.03 School Hard

The arrival of Spike. I love this character, and he's one of the main reasons this show managed to stay fresh within itself. From the beginning he shows great attitude, and it was just a small taste of things to come....

2.06 Halloween

While the problem-of-the-week might lack a little punch, Sarah Michelle Gellar get to do some fine acting taking on a completely different take to Buffy. In no way a stand-out episode in the grand scheme of things, but still really enjoyable.

2.09 & 2.10 What's My Line?

Dying has consequences, and being The Chosen One makes no exemptions to the rule. A premise-tweak that sets up greater joys later on.

2.13 Surprise (1)

Our 16 year old heroine is turning 17, and while I would never say she's a woman now... some might. My first top-rated episode on the five-star rating scale, but there were greater things to come still... even as early as at the end of the season.

2.14 Innocence (2)

When they first hit the note, they even made it back-to-back top ratings in this double feature. It's not only death that comes with consequences, and Buffy will have to deal with the fallouts of her choices. An episode that again reminds us of the delicate nuances of the character Buffy; typical high school girl/coming of age problems brings back the insecure girl as easily as demons and vampires bring The Slayer.

2.17 Passion

With life, death and souls on the line, Whedon again proofs his ability to let go. The third five-star from me.

2.21 & 2.22 Becoming, Part 1 & 2

Whedon makes his first season-ending with a bang, a trade-mark he should later perfect. Without making silly mistakes, he manages to put it all at stake --no pun intended--, and much like in first season-finale Buffy will have to face extremely difficult choices.

Buffy the Vampire Slayer, season 1

I came late to the party, but in my humble opinion Joss Whedon's Buffy the Vampire Slayer is one of the greatest 'verses ever created. The popular --and fair-- opinion is however that it doesn't really kick into its gear until season 2, making season 1 the obstacle to overcome in order to benefit from the greatness of this show. You can't really skip season 1 either, as it sets the tones, premises and relations up for later gain... so despite the extreme variations of quality and interest, season 1 is much needed to truly profit from the overall story.


Thankfully it's a bit easier to overcome the season 1 obstacle when you revisit. By then you already know how huge the reward is, making 12 small episodes a small price to pay. As I now again embark on the wonderful journey of the Buffy-verse, I can at least watch it with all the knowledge of things to come, mythologies that change, powers that will be unleashed and so on and so forth. It doesn't make up for the overall lower qualities of season 1, but I won't hold it too much against the show. After all; it eventually found its footing and elevated to incredible greatness.

1.01 ★★★☆☆ Welcome to the Hellmouth
1.02 ★★☆☆☆ The Harvest
1.03 ★☆☆☆☆ Witch
1.04 ★★☆☆☆ Teacher's Pet
1.05 ★★☆☆☆ Never Kill a Boy on the First Date
1.06 ★☆☆☆☆ The Pack
1.07 ★★★★☆ Angel
1.08 ★☆☆☆☆ I Robot, You Jane
1.09 ★★☆☆☆ The Puppet Show
1.10 ★★★☆☆ Nightmares
1.11 ★★☆☆☆ Out of Mind, Out of Sight
1.12 ★★★★☆ Prophecy Girl

S.1 ★★☆☆☆

So. While I won't go deep into spoiler-territory, I'll still dip my toe into a couple of the mini-spoiler'ish positives from this first season. And I'll do one of my vintage photo-montages of the season, with a few spoilers I'm afraid...

The main arch of season one is regarding The Master, and is no-where near those coming in later seasons quality-wise. In fact; The Master is more often boring rather than interesting or fierce. The first episode does offer some insight into the mythology and 'verse we embark on, and as such isn't a complete waste. It's still two other episodes that stand head and neck above all others bite-wise.'

1.07 Angel

While Angel have been poppin' in every so often all through the season, this is the episode where we first really touch upon one of the greatest relations of pop culture. The cursed vampire with a soul finally come out of the outskirts, and it certainly makes promises of things to come in the future.

1.12 Prophecy Girl

Where Angel was the opening act of the saga of Angel and Buffy, Prophecy Girl was the first time Buffy showed proof of what an incredible character Whedon had in mind. The 16-year old girl of her was for the first time truly shown (even if there had been glimpses earlier the season), and more importantly that same 16-year old girl took a walk... The first one of several major ones to come in the seasons that followed, and the first glimpse of the heart that shine behind all the cheese and banter. While none of the first season's episodes ever came close to really gain greatness, these two episodes are still influential and important for the Buffy-verse in hindsight. That might not be much, but it's enough....

-Buffy the Vampire Slayer # 2 : Halloween-

Cover Artists: Chris Bachalo & Tim Townsend. Colorist: Liquid!

Regular Photo Cover

Writer:	Andi Watson
Penciller:	Joe Bennett
Inker:	Rick Ketcham
Letterer:	Janice Chiang
Colorist:	Guy Major
Format:	Comic
Details:	32 pages - $2.95 US
Published:	October 28, 1998
Publisher:	Dark Horse
Story:	Halloween

Buffy #2 came from the exactly same crew as in #1, so there wasn't exactly any surprises in the art work.

Writer Andi Watson continues to show off his taste of the Buffyverse, within the limitation of ending the story within single issue. There's a nice feel for the characters throughout, and he combines different aspect well. I also find the art work improving as they become more familiar with the characters and the Sunnydale feel,... maybe with an exception for Buffy's eyes on several occasions in this number.

Overall it's a strong single-issue story, but I can hardly wait to they start doing their continuous storylines in just a few numbers. Then they'll have the room to kick it up the notch to produce absolute gold on more regular basis.

★★★★☆ # 2 -Halloween-

The cover used for post-header is my Dynamic Forces exclusive Bloodchrome edition, one of five thousand, and here's the COA.

-Buffy the Vampire Slayer: The Dust Waltz-

Writer:	Dan Brereton
Penciller:	Hector Gomez
Inker:	Sandu Florea
Letterer:	Ken Bruzenak
Colorist:	Guy Major
Format:	Trade Paperback
Details:	80 pages - $9.95 US
Published:	October 14, 1998
Publisher:	Dark Horse
Story:	The Dust Waltz

The Dust Waltz is a rarity. While most trade paperbacks released in the BTVS-series are collections of stories previous released in comic books, this one was released between #1 and #2 of the original series and contains a fresh and previously unreleased story.

I didn't exactly love the art-work here either. While Buffy is athletic, she's not an East-German project, and the latter is what springs to mind with the second drawing above. It gets better, and there's several really good drawings here, but it never quite manages to outlive that first impression. I guess Hector Gomez and Sandu Florea doesn't make my fav-list. Yet, anyway...

The story is better, and the first longer Buffy-story told in comic. Two demonic sisters with sibling issues comes for their own kind of pleasant Hellmouth experience, and our gang is quickly involved. There's banter to be had and demons to kill. It's as usual all sunny in Sunnydale. Still it doesn't quite get there. I guess Dan Brereton doesn't make my list (yet) either. All in all there's more potential than end product over The Dust Waltz.


★★★☆☆ -The Dust Waltz-

Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1992)

So. I never did get around to post why I rate "Buffy the Vampire Slayer" (the TV-show) so highly (a trained eye might have noticed it's one of a few rated at five stars), and I'm not about to do so now either. It just takes a lot of time to even come close covering half the bases I need to get the message across. I think I'll rather save it for my revisit or a special occasion.

As usual, anything Whedon, I came late to the party, but at least I bring home the sexiest girl at the end of the night. It was the same with "Firefly", and in Buffy's case I even threw in the towel after 6-7 episodes the first time I tried getting into the show. Now I can't get enough of Whedon, the Buffyverse and everything even slightly related. I'm even almost looking forward to The Avengers, after watching the first teaser with Scarlett as Black Widow doing a Buffy-esque/Faith-esque/Echo-esque Whedon-scene tied in a chair. Those with good memory might even recall Buffy Summers topping my heroines-list posted earlier this year, so it's safe to say I've become a fan-boy.

They couldn't even get the stake right...

Then it was probably about time I revisited Buffy the Vampire Slayer (the movie), at least I think it was revisiting as I seem to remember some of the stuff I just watched. I've dreaded it as I knew how Whedon felt about the end product from director Fran Rubel Kazan, but I wanted to get it out of the way before reading -The Origin- in my ongoing Buffyverse comics-reading.

It's not a great movie. It's not even a good or decent movie, but there's quite a few great one-liners whispering promises of the greatness to come from Whedon in later years. At least that's something. And there's some aspects of the Buffy-character they'd managed to get right already back then, even if it's far from the Buffy I know and love. Or to put it in the master's own words:

I finally sat down and had written it and somebody had made it into a movie, and I felt like — well, that's not quite her. It's a start, but it's not quite the girl."

Being a Buffy fan, the '92-movie shines a light on the process of creating the beloved character. As such I'm better of for having watched it. It just wasn't quite worth it on its own merits. Kristy Swanson isn't half the slayer Gellar was, Luke Perry's character is a dumber, and one-note, characteristic of Xander, and there's about thousand other reasons to hate it. It will make you giggle every so often, and witty writing isn't something you get across every day. As such there's something to be said for cult-ifying movies like this. Still I doubt I'll ever watch it again. I scored it at 30/100 at my Criticker-rating, and that's not very impressive no matter how strict I usually come across to others.

-Buffy the Vampire Slayer # 1 : Wu-Tang Fang-

Cover Artist: Art Adams

Regular photo cover

Writer:	Andi Watson
Penciller:	Joe Bennett
Inker:	Rick Ketcham
Letterer:	Janice Chiang
Colorist:	Guy Major
Format:	Comic
Details:	32 pages - $2.95 US
Published:	September 23, 1998
Publisher:	Dark Horse
Story:	Wu-Tang Fang

Whatever concerns I had with MacGuffins, wasn't exactly put at ease with the opening page of Buffy's own # 1.

It's not the semi-bimbo Ross gave us, but Bennett's opening Buffy isn't exactly oozing nailed-it either.

Thankfully writer Andi Watson only use a couple of pages to convince me he's nailed-it. He's captured the essence of Buffy in every way. I find myself hearing the lines as spoken by the actors and actresses them self in the TV-show, and a bigger complement is impossible to give. He understands the humor, he get the banter and puns in whether it's dialogue or fight scenes, and it balances the dark and the light in Whedonesque fashion. Add several small and bigger references to prior events and current circumstances in the TV-series, and it's pretty clear Mr. Watson and the editor knows exactly what is needed.

The artwork also draw me in as page by page run by, and soon enough it's familiar and almost there. The darkness and shadows are very well done, the bad guys and fight scenes are well drawn and only a few of the main characters remain an issue for me every so often. It still can't take away the joy of this comic, with its story that adds to the well known and familiar TV-series with a well deserved new life on its comic own.

Overall there's no doubt this is an incredible tight opening issue of own comic, and must have brought in a lot of the TV-audience as sure buyers for future releases.

★★★★☆ # 1 -Wu-Tang Fang-

Special and alternate variants I also own:

COA for Dynamic Forces Art cover signed by Art Adams as one of 10.000 copies. The comic used as header for this post.

Another Universe exclusive Gold Foil edition of photo cover

Another Universe exclusive Gold Foil edition of photo cover, signed by Joe Bennett (COA below)

Dark Horse 1 for 1 re-release

-Buffy the Vampire Slayer: MacGuffins-

Cover Artist: Mike Mignola

Writer:	J.L. Van Meter
Penciller:	Luke Ross
Inker:	Rick Ketcham
Letterer:	Steve Dutro
Colorist:	Guy Major
Format:	Comic
Details:	64 pages - $4.95 US
Published:	August 26, 1998
Publisher:	Dark Horse
Story:	MacGuffins

Buffy's first comic release, -MacGuffins-, was just a short story in this publisher collection alongside Hellboy and others.

I doubt anyone could have predicted the impact Buffy's entrance into the comic-world eventually would have. No disrespect to any of the artists involved, but they didn't exactly catch the spirit of Buffy in this attempt. Well, with the exception of writer Van Meter. He actually managed to write a little story that captured a lot of Buffy's core and that Sunnydale-feel, despite not even taking place in Sunnydale. The art-work from Ross and Ketchum did however leave me feeling like they had no idea who Buffy was. Their Buffy felt like a semi-bimbo, and that's no way to threat The Chosen One.

★★☆☆☆ -MacGuffins-